Union's Season Ends In Disappointing 1-0 Loss
It seemed so fitting. So perfect, even. The Philadelphia Union were seeking their first ever playoff match victory and playoff series victory in the same place where they took their first-ever road victory, and opened their second season with a victory: Robertson Stadium in Houston. But it was not to be. An improbable season for the Union ended predictably with a set-piece goal against and not enough offense for.
After a somewhat promising first 45 minutes, if only for the fact that the Union hadn't conceded anything, Brad Davis and Brian Ching teamed up in likely the last kick in first half stoppage time on a Houston freekick. Two experts combining to take advantage of arguably the Union's biggest weakness, and give the Dynamo a backbreaking 3-1 lead in the aggregate that they would not relinquish. But let's spare the details of this match. You know what happened. Rubbing salt in these fresh wounds does no one any good. There are plenty of questions to be asked about Piotr Nowak's strategies for this match, and they'll undoubtedly be repeated for the next five months.
It's not exactly all bad, though.
Who expected last October 24, after the Union concluded their inaugural season with a 3-1 loss in Columbus, that their core would get younger and that they'd make the playoffs? Probably not that many people. But with additional young talent on hand, and Faryd Mondragon and Carlos Valdes -- who were all that they were hyped up to be -- what merely seemed like a possibility became a reality, with the Union making the MLS Cup playoffs.
Yes, the mid-season losses of Jordan Harvey and Carlos Ruiz will probably be brought up as the turning point in the season, where Philadelphia went from Eastern Conference contender to somewhat above average. The much-heralded acquisition of Freddy Adu ended up being underwhelming. On the other hand, though, Sebastien Le Toux's 2010 season was clearly not a fluke, though. Zac MacMath has proved that the Union picked a real gem in the first round of this year's MLS SuperDraft. Gabriel and Michael Farfan showed versatility. The importance of the understated acquisition of Brian Carroll cannot be overstated. Zach Pfeffer is on his way. Sheanon Williams picked up right where he left off at the end of last season and was simply marvelous.
Where do the Union go from here? There will be much time this offseason to try and answer this question, but on the surface, it seems as though the only option is for them to continue to go up. As their younger talent continues to develop, one cannot imagine any other outcome for their third season. Yes, the team will probably look to bring in outside talent -- Gabriel Farfan has been playing out of position at left back and frankly doesn't appear to be ready to take on a full-time starting role on the backline yet, and it's clear that the Union lost something very important with Carlos Ruiz. The future, however, looks to be very bright. That much is indisputable, and is something for Union fans to hang their hats on for the next five months. The Union took their fans on an unexpectedly positive ride from March through to tonight, and, ultimately, for that, we can only be grateful.
9 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Great team. Great season. Great young core.
We’ll be back.
Editor at SB Nation's Philadelphia Union blog, The Brotherly Game. Follow me on Twitter.
For those that want negatives
Nowak is really beginning to get on my nerves. Not sure if it is time to call for a firing yet, but his propensity to outcoach himself like he did in this series really is irritating to say the least. Hopefully he improves next year, otherwise, it may be time to seek out a replacement.
Editor at SB Nation's Philadelphia Union blog, The Brotherly Game. Follow me on Twitter.
I think this is why it’s hard for me to get too down on Adu or the other young guys. There is no consistency with players’ positions, formations, lineups, ect. It’s hard enough to come into a team mid-season and make an impact, and it’s even more difficult to this when you’re constantly being shifted into different roles. Maybe Nowak would be a genius managing like this in the Bundisliga, but this kind of inconsistency doesn’t work in MLS (i.e. FC Dallas with Jackson). I think the inaccurate passing is a clear example of this. It seems our players aren’t able to recognize off the ball movements from teammates because the lineup is always shuffled.
Anyways, it was an exciting season and it’s great to see the Union accomplish something other expansion teams have struggled to do in only year two. I can’t wait to see what the offseason holds for the U!
I dunno, I give Nowak a lot of credit for getting them to where he did this season. This is not a very talented team and I think his organization built them that base of points in the first half of the season.
I think the inaccurate passing is a clear example of the lack of talent more than it is coaching.
Follow Bleeding Green Nation on Twitter & Facebook. Did you get your copy of the 2011 Eagles Annual yet?
The best part is...
…this is year #2 of a long trek ahead to the top. From an outsider’s perspective, i.e. someone who can’t watch all the games and whatnot, due to being relocated to CT, it’s awesome that we (Philly) have another team to cheer for and root on. Philly has been deprived of soccer for quite some time and the fact that we’ve quickly risen into contention makes this loss sting a little bit less. Yes, it would have been amazing that we could be in the Conf. Finals, but the fact that we made it this far and there were some set backs just sets the bar higher for next season and now making the playoffs is almost expected, versus “oh it’s great we made the playoffs”.
(Applause)
Listen, you guys were playing with house money. You’re an expansion team and conventional wisdom says that you have no business in the post-season (see: Whitecaps, Vancouver) yet there you guys were going at it. You have actually a very talented team that is still relatively young but has just enough veterans to keep the team grounded. You just need someone in the middle who can really help control, possess and dictate the flow of the game from the back to the front. You’ve got someone in LeToux who can and will be a danger man, though it’d be wise to pick up someone else who can help take the pressure off him and provide another consistent scoring threat. Other than that, I’d honestly say your defensive frailties might be more due to coaching than anything else. Other than that, bright future ahead and its awesome to see what you guys are doing with this site and your growing footie community. Keep it up
/PS – if we start doing you guys like the Astros do the Phillies in terms of handing them talent, I take it all back :)
That's not true
“Conventional wisdom” doesn’t tell you anything about expansion teams in MLS.
In any other league in the country, people would still refer to the Dynamo as an expansion team given how young that franchise is.
Follow Bleeding Green Nation on Twitter & Facebook. Did you get your copy of the 2011 Eagles Annual yet?
On one hand...
I really wonder about the tone that gets set when there are things like champagne celebrations after the disappointing draw versus Toronto, or Nowak last night railing against the officiating and essentially saying the Union were the better team. I think there was/is a way to accentuate the positives of this season while also making sure that there’s accountability and that these young players know losing should always be considered unacceptable (in the sense that while losing will happen, it should never be accepted).
On the other hand, this team is so young that I can see why Nowak feels he needs to protect them somewhat and point fingers elsewhere. If the manager is too hard on them, he risks losing them. And they did deserve some fun for making the playoffs, even if it was in the form of Naka spraying champagne on everyone. It’s a tricky spot to be in. Really, the whole organization was in a tricky spot this entire season – I think all year long they struggled with being ahead of their own plan and timetable.
I just hope they keep building and keep working. It would be really easy for the players and the organization to get a little too comfortable amidst all the “bright future” talk.

by 


















